• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to GoreMade Pizza

Built on a foundation of artisanal craft, GoreMade Pizza in Columbus, OH is a hidden gem for pizza enthusiasts. Using fresh local ingredients, their rustic charred dough and unique toppings set them apart. With a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service, diners enjoy a personalized dining experience. From the mouthwatering cheesy garlic bread to the perfectly sized 12 pizzas or pizza boats, every dish is a tantalizing delight. Whether opting for classic flavors or bold creations, GoreMade Pizza is a top contender for best pizza in Columbus, earning a spot on many locals' must-visit list. Every visit leaves you craving more of their inventive and delicious offerings.

GoreMade Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Tony F.
Tony F.

Food was perfect, the dough cooked wth the perfect char rustic basic tomato sauce and fresh local ingredients. Will definitely be back and went to my top 5 list of cbus pizzas

Gregory F.
Gregory F.

Outstanding pizzas that are fairly lesser known throughout town. I love this place - truly well made (or should I say "gore-made") pizzas with a personalized flare. Everytime I go here, I leave with a smile - I wish I also left with leftovers, but the pizzas are just too good. Great service, fun decor, everything is just so fun.

Peter T.
Peter T.

Didn't know this place existed until recently, and it's right down the street from my place. The cheesy garlic bread is amazing - a must try! The pizzas come in a round 12" or you can get the pizza boat, which is half sized. I really enjoy thin-crust pizza and I think this place is my favorite in Columbus so far. They definitely have some unique toppings to choose from. I went with a basic pizza, but will have to try their pesto next time I'm there. There is an outdoor area available with decent amount of seating, which I did not know at first!

Michael G.
Michael G.

Always great. Server team was on it tonight. There was a Crew game tonight so it was very busy. We arrived at 530 and got a good table. The balsamic on the salad is really great. So is The Old Fashion. The water is cold! A Top 10 pizza in the area.

Ann S.
Ann S.

Excellent, excellent pizza! My daughter has been raving about this place, and I was skeptical. But geez. This was so delicious! We got a Clintonvillain subbing the mushrooms for olives, and a Chef 's Choice Pizza -- also delicious!! Great crust, amazing toppings! A small pizza joint with a small bar and 6 or so tables. I'm sure they do a robust carry-out business but we sat at a table by the window. Helpful employees, who are clearly proud of their product. Street parking. We'll be back!

John B.
John B.

The pizza is awesome Service spectacular The ambiance is perfect for a pizza shop. The only complaint is parking. You will have to find parking and it can be difficult and you may have a long walk. With that said I take a star away. 4 stars

Location

Welcome to GoreMade Pizza, where pizza is not just a meal, it's an experience. Located at 936 N 4th St in Columbus, OH, this hidden gem offers a unique dining experience with a touch of personalized flair.

GoreMade Pizza is more than just your average pizza joint. With a menu that caters to vegetarians and meat-lovers alike, there is something for everyone to enjoy. From their perfectly charred rustic dough to their fresh local ingredients, each bite is a burst of flavor that will keep you coming back for more.

Customer reviews rave about the outstanding pizzas at GoreMade Pizza. From the cheesy garlic bread to the unique toppings available, every dish is made with care and attention to detail. The personalized service and fun decor add to the overall charm of this cozy eatery.

Whether you're looking for a casual meal with friends or a quick bite to eat, GoreMade Pizza has you covered. With options for delivery, takeout, and even catering, you can enjoy their delicious pizzas wherever you are. So why not stop by and experience the magic of GoreMade Pizza for yourself? Your taste buds will thank you.